Dr. Jan Burkins
  • Home
  • The Six Shifts
  • Online Classes
  • Consulting
  • Reading Art
  • About
  • Jan's Books
  • Contact
  • WDTW 3-5 Lesson Set Kits

"The Science of Reading" and "Balanced Literacy"

10/24/2019

8 Comments

 
​Most of us are painfully aware of the fissure in literacy education that is being exacerbated by polarizing and unproductive language around “The Science of Reading” and “Balanced Literacy.” I have been watching in the wings thinking about how to support collegial conversations and honest reflections. 

Kim Yaris and I met on Twitter in 2012 when the literacy world was similarly, if not as fiercely, divided over the development of the Common Core State Standards. As we dug into the research around the CCSS and considered the political landscape of the field and the way it impacted the issues, we found lots of voices preaching to their own choirs and wondered how we could bring together an audience that might consider the truth on either side of the issue. 

We eventually set about to look deeply and honestly at what was being overlooked from each perspective. During this period, if you read our blog on one day, you might leave thinking that we were staunch advocates of the CCSS (and you would have been correct). If you read the blog on another day, you might come away thinking that we were fierce critics and were at determined odds with the CCSS and their “architects” (and you would also have been correct).

As many of us are hesitant to admit in this current debate, the “truth” is not at all absolute. I am convinced, however, that we don’t have to position ourselves as polar opposites, unless we just want to fight. And I don’t think that is the case.

After many emails, direct messages, and personal requests to share my thinking on this topic and dig into the controversy, I am launching this blog to begin an inquiry into what divides us and where we can come together. Beware. Even if you typically agree with my thinking-- individually or as part of Burkins & Yaris--and regardless of where you stand on the perceived continuum between “The Science of Reading” and “Balanced Literacy,” it is likely that you won’t always like what I have to say.

I will start here, throwing a monkey wrench into the science of science:  Generally speaking, research needs to be viewed with a healthy dose of skepticism. Even the accumulation of research that seems to support a consistent claim--and we offer this thought for either perspective on this issue--is problematic when all the studies share a similar flaw or bias. 

So I leave you thinking about the ways we, humans, tend to find what we want to believe in research while we overlook what we don’t really want to see. On this note, we share this very R-rated video of John Oliver talking about the importance of and the limitations of science. If you are easily offended (or even somewhat easily offended), we recommend that you limit yourself to this summary:

In sum, it is easy to misrepresent studies in ways that support what we already believe and there is an element of sensationalism that comes from snagging catchy tidbits from studies without scrutinizing the design and the potential biases. 

8 Comments
Mary Howard
10/24/2019 12:33:21 pm

I am so grateful to you for raising these conversations. In record time, we have created the GREAT DIVIDE where there is a great deal of mudslinging between these two topics but very little open-minded conversation. I believe that your efforts will make all he difference in the world. Thank you Jan. This is phenomenal!

Reply
Jan Burkins link
10/31/2019 03:24:42 am

I appreciate your encouragement, Mary. I really want to look closely at what each side is saying and what truth is in it, without mudslinging!

Reply
Elaine Shobert
10/24/2019 01:20:43 pm

I applaud your courage and am perched on the edge of my seat waiting for more.

Reply
Jan Burkins link
10/31/2019 03:26:37 am

Thank you, Elaine. I don't feel courageous. Perhaps I am naive. I have a lot of faith in most folks on both sides of this "debate."

Reply
Kari Yates link
10/24/2019 08:05:33 pm

I'm so excited to be part of this brave journey! You are uniquely positioned to lead a courageous conversation about this topic on behalf of the the children. Here's to deeper listening, open minds, and finding a path forward that brings out the best in all of us . . .

Reply
Jan Burkins link
10/31/2019 03:27:17 am

Such a lovely comment, Kari. I so appreciate your support and encouragement.

Reply
Christina Nosek
10/25/2019 10:22:54 am

Jan, I applaud you for taking this challenging topic on! I am really looking forward learning more from you over time. Thank you for all you do to move our field and our thinking forward.

Reply
Jan Burkins link
10/31/2019 03:30:13 am

Thank you so much, Christina. I find it all so fascinating. It will be an interesting journey. :)

Reply



Leave a Reply.

      Follow This Blog . . .

    Submit
    FREE BOOKS

    Author

    Dr. Jan Burkins is a full-time writer, consultant, and professional development provider. 

    Categories

    All
    Assessment
    Asynchronous
    Back To School
    Back-to-school
    Balance
    Balanced Literacy
    Beginning Reading
    Books
    Breathing
    Classroom Library
    Comprehension
    Cue
    Decoding
    Distance Learning
    Educational Technology
    Fluency
    Free Books
    Guided Reading
    Hybrid Models
    Independent Reading
    Mask
    Masks
    Meaning
    Mental Models
    Mindfulness
    Morphemes
    New Year
    Personal Growth
    Phonemic Awareness
    Phonological Awareness
    Planning
    Preventing Misguided Reading
    Print
    Prompt
    Prompting
    Prompting Funnel
    Questioning
    Racism
    Read Aloud
    Reading Wars
    Reflection
    Research
    Routines
    Schedule
    Science Of Reading
    Shared Reading
    Social Justice
    SoR
    Sources Of Information
    Stories
    Synchronous
    Technology
    Text Selection
    The Great Debate
    Unit
    Virtual
    Virtual Guided Reading
    Vocabulary Instruction
    Wait Time
    Whiteness
    Who's Doing The Work?

    RSS Feed

Jan Miller Burkins Consulting, LLC
1720 Epps Bridge Parkway , Suite 108, #419, Athens, GA 30606

    Follow this blog/newsletter.

Submit

Contact Jan

  • Home
  • The Six Shifts
  • Online Classes
  • Consulting
  • Reading Art
  • About
  • Jan's Books
  • Contact
  • WDTW 3-5 Lesson Set Kits