Dr. Jan Burkins
  • Home
  • The Six Shifts
  • Online Classes
  • Consulting
  • Reading Art
  • About
  • Jan's Books
  • Contact
  • WDTW 3-5 Lesson Set Kits

how to make the most of our questions Even across cyberspace

9/20/2020

0 Comments

 
Picture
Image by 愚木混株 Cdd20 from Pixabay.

​Who's Doing the Work? (Burkins & Yaris, 2016) explores the ways we support students in problem-solving, especially if they are grappling with something that is really requiring them to think deeply and work hard. Right now, when so much about our instruction is different than usual, asking good questions is a reliable and familiar friend.

Of course, we all know that asking higher-order questions can help children learn more. But, while asking "good" questions remains important in mask-to-mask and digital spaces, it's what we do after we ask the question that matters next.

I recently encountered, however, a bit of research on math instruction that is making me think about the limits of these "good" questions.

In a study that compared the way math teachers ask questions during math instruction, researchers found that only 1 in 5 questions required children to make deep connections across the content. This does not seem like big news; we are all aware of the need to ask more questions that push children to take the content they are learning to levels of analysis and connection. We also appreciate the important role that procedural questions ("low level") play when learning new information or processes. Certainly, it would be silly to try and make every question higher- order.

What is most fascinating about the study mentioned in Range, however, is that in many cases, when better questions were asked, children still didn't get the opportunity to think deeply about the content. Rather than actually getting to do the work, they were given a series of "hints." So even though the work began with an invitation into deep thinking, their thinking was actually hampered during the process of answering the question.

While 1/5 of questions in the study were high-level questions, requiring students to deeply process the content, students received hint after hint in the form of a low-level question. So, low-level, hint-giving questions, eliminated the value of the original, good question.

Historically, in developing better questions for reading instruction, we put a lot of energy into thinking about levels of inquiry and Blooms Taxonomy. We craft the questions thoughtfully, but  the moments after the initial question matter just as much as the question. In fact, with hint-giving through a series of low-level questions, a question such as, How do authors show the ways characters change over time? becomes no more thought-provoking or learning-inducing than a question like, Who is the main character? 

Fortunately, there is a magic bullet for letting our better questions do the work we intend for them to do. The simple practice for making the most of our good questions it to, quite simply, wait.

​Wait time is the critical complement to a good question, and it is proving even more tricky in virtual instruction. A few seconds can feel like forever when you are up close on a camera screen. Instructional time is somehow different in this new time-space-continuum. But just because it feels like forever, doesn't mean it actually is forever. In virtual instruction especially, and in light of the negative effects of "hint" giving to move things along, just giving students time to think remains essential.

Now more than ever, the way we support students in answering questions is just as important as the question itself. 



0 Comments

      Follow This Blog . . .

    Submit
    FREE BOOKS

    Author

    Dr. Jan Burkins is a full-time writer, consultant, and professional development provider. 

    Categories

    All
    Assessment
    Asynchronous
    Back To School
    Back-to-school
    Balance
    Balanced Literacy
    Beginning Reading
    Books
    Breathing
    Classroom Library
    Comprehension
    Cue
    Decoding
    Distance Learning
    Educational Technology
    Fluency
    Free Books
    Guided Reading
    Hybrid Models
    Independent Reading
    Mask
    Masks
    Meaning
    Mental Models
    Mindfulness
    Morphemes
    New Year
    Personal Growth
    Phonemic Awareness
    Phonological Awareness
    Planning
    Preventing Misguided Reading
    Print
    Prompt
    Prompting
    Prompting Funnel
    Questioning
    Racism
    Read Aloud
    Reading Wars
    Reflection
    Research
    Routines
    Schedule
    Science Of Reading
    Shared Reading
    Social Justice
    SoR
    Sources Of Information
    Stories
    Synchronous
    Technology
    Text Selection
    The Great Debate
    Unit
    Virtual
    Virtual Guided Reading
    Vocabulary Instruction
    Wait Time
    Whiteness
    Who's Doing The Work?

    RSS Feed

Jan Miller Burkins Consulting, LLC
1720 Epps Bridge Parkway , Suite 108, #419, Athens, GA 30606

    Follow this blog/newsletter.

Submit

Contact Jan

  • Home
  • The Six Shifts
  • Online Classes
  • Consulting
  • Reading Art
  • About
  • Jan's Books
  • Contact
  • WDTW 3-5 Lesson Set Kits