Dr. Jan Burkins
  • Home
  • The Six Shifts
  • Online Classes
  • Consulting
  • Reading Art
  • About
  • Jan's Books
  • Contact
  • WDTW 3-5 Lesson Set Kits

Space for Approximations: More Hacks for Guided Reading in Virtual Spaces

10/30/2020

5 Comments

 
Picture
Sometimes, when we are trying to solve a problem we place limitations on ourselves because of tradition. We don't "think outside of the box" because we have come to consider the box as somehow integral to the process. It helps to sometimes bring to the foreground and scrutinize the barriers that we place on ourselves. So, what is limiting our thinking about guided reading, the trickiest instructional context to shift to digital platforms?

While read aloud, shared reading, and even independent reading and conferences seem to translate to virtual spaces with less disruption to the model, guided reading remains the more challenging instructional context to teach over a computer.


In addition to the intrinsic challenge of teaching across cyberspace, the fact that probably no one else has your school district's exact model makes it harder to crowdsource the problems. I am endlessly amazed by all the different ways districts give shape to teaching in 2020 (and soon 2021).

In this blog, Hacks for Virtual Guided Reading, I explored some intuitive suggestions for navigating guided reading in virtual spaces, including a suggestion for how to listen to individual students read during virtual guided reading. I recently worked with a school where a teacher was really problem-solving how do just this thing, but she needed a different solution than the one I offered in the previous blog.

Her students all had access to district-provided laptops, so that eliminated one barrier that is present for some. In my conversation with the teacher, I realized that we were assuming some pre-virtual conditions that didn't necessarily have to apply. We found that adjusting away from those limitations helped us meet the goal of listening to students read instructional level texts, even though they weren't face to face.

Here were some of our assumptions:

  • Running records need to happen synchronously.
  • Guided reading sessions are a continuous time block.
  • Listening to individual children read during guided reading must happen while the other children remain in the group and read silently.
  • If children see the guided reading text before the lesson, it will be spoiled.
  • Running records during guided reading should be "cold reads."

As it turns out, none of these assumptions is requisite to guided reading instruction. Questioning all of the aforementioned beliefs, we developed a plan.

On Fridays, she is going to give her guided reading groups their texts via links placed on the school's virtual platform. Over the weekend, students will record themselves reading using either video, or simply audio. Students will send their teacher their recordings by Monday.

During the week, she will listen to a few student recordings each day, as she had done when guided reading was face-to-face, and take running records.  If a student is having difficulty, she will check in with that student via whatever tool seems appropriate. When the group gets together to talk about the book, they can engage in some choral reading of the text and have conversations about it.

Again, there are things about this variation on the guided reading model that don't work as well as face-to-face guided reading. You may or may not find out how a child navigates a first-read in a text, although you may be able to specify that you want a first read in the directions. Either way, there are worse problems than a child practicing a text to sound good when they read it to you. If children see their recordings as something to practice and perfect, what we lose in cold-read data we gain in repeated readings practice and reading growth. 

There remains a driving need to work with small groups in virtual spaces. While none of the creative solutions out there seem to be perfect, many of us are finding that a pandemic is a great time to embrace approximations and explore not being a perfectionist.

If you explore this model or some aspect of it, I would love to hear about what you figure out. You can always reach me at tct.jan@gmail.com, or you can leave a comment on this post.







5 Comments
Jennifer Sniadecki link
11/2/2020 05:33:44 am

It's funny how these assumptions, when written down and studied, are only barriers if we place them on ourselves. I think your solution here is a good one; the students can still read, and the teacher can still have individual conferring sessions.

Have a nice day!

Reply
Molly James link
11/2/2020 09:11:50 pm

My two favorite lines ...

"It helps to sometimes bring to the foreground and scrutinize the barriers that we place on ourselves." This seems so valuable to me! Not only for teaching reading, but teaching anything ... AND, for my self and my life. what are the barriers I am placing? Wow. Thanks!

"While none of the creative solutions out there seem to be perfect, many of us are finding that a pandemic is a great time to embrace approximations and explore not being a perfectionist.' Again, such a great thing to consider doing - approximate and breathe through not being perfect! :D I've been trying to do that with my art, and I'm loving the process and product. Sometimes I have to breathe a little more, lol, but I love it.

Thanks very much, Jan!

Reply
Gabriela link
11/23/2020 07:48:29 pm

Hello! I really like how you were able to come up with a solution for guided reading and running records, although it might not be face to face it sounds like it will work. Embracing the moment and making the best of it is definitely the way to go.

Thank you for sharing this!

Reply
Denise link
12/29/2020 10:51:15 am

I have been using the "turn the volume down" for silent reading and then "turn the volume up" for the one reading to me. While this has worked to some degree, the students' ability to have multiple screens to see the text is the bigger problem. Split screen can be tricky for readers so they are stuck reading and rereading a page, thereby interrupting the free flow of the text to create optimum comprehension and enjoyment of the text. I agree that we have to forego the "perfect guided reading" lesson and make concessions. I am definitely going to try the protocol of having students read the text in its entirety beforehand resulting in a submission of a recording. This makes so much sense on so many fronts and like you said was "hiding in plain sight". Thank you for your common sense approach, Dr. Burkins!

Reply
Hugo link
6/18/2022 08:16:27 pm

This iss a great post

Reply



Leave a Reply.

      Follow This Blog . . .

    Submit
    FREE BOOKS

    Author

    Dr. Jan Burkins is a full-time writer, consultant, and professional development provider. 

    Categories

    All
    Assessment
    Asynchronous
    Back To School
    Back-to-school
    Balance
    Balanced Literacy
    Beginning Reading
    Books
    Breathing
    Classroom Library
    Comprehension
    Cue
    Decoding
    Distance Learning
    Educational Technology
    Fluency
    Free Books
    Guided Reading
    Hybrid Models
    Independent Reading
    Mask
    Masks
    Meaning
    Mental Models
    Mindfulness
    Morphemes
    New Year
    Personal Growth
    Phonemic Awareness
    Phonological Awareness
    Planning
    Preventing Misguided Reading
    Print
    Prompt
    Prompting
    Prompting Funnel
    Questioning
    Racism
    Read Aloud
    Reading Wars
    Reflection
    Research
    Routines
    Schedule
    Science Of Reading
    Shared Reading
    Social Justice
    SoR
    Sources Of Information
    Stories
    Synchronous
    Technology
    Text Selection
    The Great Debate
    Unit
    Virtual
    Virtual Guided Reading
    Vocabulary Instruction
    Wait Time
    Whiteness
    Who's Doing The Work?

    RSS Feed

Jan Miller Burkins Consulting, LLC
1720 Epps Bridge Parkway , Suite 108, #419, Athens, GA 30606

    Follow this blog/newsletter.

Submit

Contact Jan

  • Home
  • The Six Shifts
  • Online Classes
  • Consulting
  • Reading Art
  • About
  • Jan's Books
  • Contact
  • WDTW 3-5 Lesson Set Kits