Dr. Jan Burkins
  • Home
  • The Six Shifts
  • Online Classes
  • Consulting
  • Reading Art
  • About
  • Jan's Books
  • Contact
  • WDTW 3-5 Lesson Set Kits

K-5 Lessons for Launching the School Year

8/1/2020

18 Comments

 
Picture
Dear Friends,

For the last couple of weeks I have been making something for you.

Inspired by my son's pen pal relationship this summer, I ordered every book I could find that involved characters who write letters. I read them all carefully, considering how some could work together around the theme, Mail Myself to You.

Finally, I wrote a set of K-5 lessons--including Reading Art, Read Aloud, Shared Reading, Small Group Instruction, and Independent Reading. I've assembled these lessons in a tabbed hyperdoc--a pdf that links to sections within the document, as well as to sources outside the document. It includes videos of me describing the books and the lessons, written descriptions of each lesson, and ideas for extension. The lessons are clustered: kindergarten-1st, 2nd-3rd, and 4th-5th. 

The lessons are free, with a subscription to my blog/newsletter. If you complete the contact form below, I will email you personally, including the 25-page, linked PDF as an attachment (Please, give me 24 hours to respond). Or, if you want to write to me directly to request the document, my email is tct.jan@gmail.com.

I am excited to share this collection of resources with you. They have been a labor of love. 

Wishing you all good things,
Jan


​

    Follow this blog/newsletter.

Submit
18 Comments

Making Masks Friendly: PROBLEM-SOLVING BACK-TO-SCHOOL 2020 (POST #3)

7/28/2020

15 Comments

 
Picture
I've really been thinking about some of the ramifications of mask wearing, and wondering how to make them a little friendlier for young children. I decided it might soften mask wearing a bit if some of the characters on the front of picture books on the back-to-school shelf were wearing masks. For the most part, it was a pretty easy craft project for a rainy afternoon. All-in-all, it took me about 40 minutes to figure it out and apply masks to the characters on the covers of a handful of books.

Here's what you will need:
  • Books
  • Tracing paper (I used parchment paper out of the kitchen, but any thin paper will do.)
  • A pencil or pen that won't bleed
  • Scissors
  • Adhesive/removable film. I used Cricut Removable Vinyl.

Here's the process:
  1. Choose a book. You will need books where the faces of the characters are large enough on the cover. You need their faces to be unobstructed by their hands or the faces of other characters (unless you want to do a more complicated masking job). Also, the placement of their eyes, nose, and mouth matter. If the nose is almost on the same plane as the eyes, then it becomes hard to draw a mask on the face. I was also intentional about selecting books with slick covers, as it seems that would make it easier to eventually remove the masks.
  2. Trace the face. Use tracing paper to trace the face of the character on the cover. I found it helpful to include the ears, eyes, and mouth. I even traced the hair, just because it gave me a better sense of how the final product would look. 
  3. Draw the mask. Draw a mask on the tracing of the face. Start from the top of one ear and go to the top of the next. Repeat, drawing a line from the bottom of one ear to the next. On the sides, the mask curves in. You will have to modify this, depending on how the characters are drawn. For example, I put a mask on a bear and a fox, neither of which had ears that easily translated to drawing a mask. 
  4. Trim the tracing. Trim down your drawing by cutting widely around the mask. This will involve cutting up the drawing of the face, which is okay, since you are only going to need the mask.
  5. Cut the vinyl. Cut a piece of vinyl a little larger than the mask. Put the vinyl behind your drawing. If your vinyl and your tracing paper were both in rolls, you may find it helpful to make sure they are both curved in the same direction, so that they don't fight each other. Also, when I used a light color, such as yellow, I found I had to double the vinyl.
  6. Cut out the mask. With the drawing against the vinyl, cut through both to cut out the mask. You will have to make sure that you don't let them wiggle, but keep the same alignment through the whole process.
  7. Adhere the mask. Remove the backing from the vinyl. The adhesive vinyl I used was pretty forgiving; I could pull it off and reaffix it as I needed to. There was a bit of trial and error with applying each of the masks.
  8. Cut and affix. If you want to cut thin strips of white vinyl to make the elastic for the mask, then that is the last step. I found it easier to remove the backing from the vinyl before cutting these really thin strips.

Here are a few images of the process:
​
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
When I started this project, I just randomly picked titles that seemed to have characters on the cover that would were large enough to apply a mask on their faces. I was not picking books that were necessarily the best books for launching the school year, although some might be viable options. 

While this is not a sophisticated or comprehensive solution to softening mask-wearing, it may prove a conversation starter or at least something to engage students. At the very least, this is a fun way to think about how masks can cover our expressions. You could even pull back the film to reveal the expressions of the characters. This project seems to be fun, whether you are sharing books virtually or in person.

​Perhaps, if you begin school "face-to-face," they should go on your shelf six-feet apart.

Note: After I had completed the project, my children pointed out that the bird on Rocked Writes a Story didn't get masked! I had already put up my materials, at that point. If I were sharing the book with children, I would mask all of the characters on the cover.  
15 Comments

Navigating the Maze of Computerized Instruction: Problem-Solving Back-to-School 2020 (Post #2)

7/26/2020

0 Comments

 
Picture
Image by OpenClipart-Vectors from Pixabay.

Before social distancing and home learning began in March, schools were already wrestling with the role that computers should play in classrooms. Whether weighing the decision to go to one-to-one devices for all students or navigating district mandates to use a certain program, reflective educators have long known that what makes technology helpful is the way it is used. But figuring out how to use it often means navigating a maze of mandates, program implications, and student needs.

A couple of years ago, in one elementary school where I consulted, the district required that schools use a particular program to identify and address reading difficulties. I walked into a first-grade classroom in October to find about half of the first-graders working on iPads. They were using a computer program to learn phonemic awareness, letters, and sounds. Their iPad screens were filled with images of things like an apple, to which the narrator would say something like, “A is for apple. A says /a/.”

It seemed strange to me that in October of first-grade so many students would need such rudimentary skills work. I asked the teacher about it. She said that all of her students had taken a placement test with the same computer program and that they were doing the lessons that the computer indicated they needed. I was skeptical. 

I asked the teacher if I could administer individual assessments with the students. When she agreed, I took each student out into the hall one at a time and administered Hearing and Recording Sounds, Marie Clay’s (2013) simple, first-grade assessment. Students had to write two connected sentences: I have a big dog at home. Today I am going to take him to school. 

Many of the students that the computer indicated should begin with lessons like, “Apple starts with A” were actually able to write the two sentences perfectly! Most of the other students were able to write reasonable sound-spellings for each of the phonemes in those sentences (e.g. skool for school). Every single child in the class already knew the sound for short A. 

I talked to the teacher. She explained that she was required to follow the directions of the computer program. I talked to the principal, who described the same district requirements and said there was no way to skip lessons in the program. All those children had to sit through all the very beginning reading lessons, even those who already knew all the letter sounds. 

Now that distance learning is the norm, reliance on large expensive programs to discern what children need--and to address those needs instructionally--seems to be on the rise. However, children actually need real teachers now more than ever. 

In a conversation with the literacy leadership in an elementary school where I am working throughout this school year (virtually and traveling by car when it is safe), they are dealing with district requirements to use a widespread monster program. They are frustrated, but they are trying to make it work for them. If you are trying to make the most of a required, comprehensive computer program, here are some things to consider:

  • Are there aspects of the computerized assessment that you can easily use to inform your instruction? For example, does the program record children reading? If so, great! Listen to those recordings yourself, analyze the miscues, and add them to your body of data about your students. Does the computer offer you timed readings? Great! Calculate words-per-minute and see where students fall along fluency norms for their grade. 
  • Does the computer confirm or refute what you know about your students? Listen to your students read and consider whether your observations align with the results the computer found. If there is a discrepancy, dig deeper. 
  • Do you have the option of assigning lessons rather than letting the computer assign lessons? If so, assign lessons to students based on your assessments of them, even if that includes your considerations of the results from the computer.

In the end, computers can’t serve children well unless we use them well. Making the most of the tool you have been given, or even that you are required to use, means knowing that tool and knowing your students. This knowledge will help you maximize a program’s benefits while sidestepping it’s limitations, navigating the maze to your students' advantage.


Clay, Marie M. (2013). An observation survey of early literacy achievement (3rd Ed.). Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.


0 Comments

Microphones and Masks: Problem-solving Back-to-school 2020 (Post #1)

7/23/2020

6 Comments

 
Picture
Image credit: Image by Sumanley xulx from Pixabay

​One of the big challenges with wearing a mask is being heard and understood. This may be particularly problematic for "face-to-face" learning this fall, when children are necessarily very spread out. Reading aloud, for example, to a group that is widely spread throughout the room would have its own challenges without a mask.

​In the video below, I show you how to use a personal voice amplifier while wearing a mask. The microphone is not a perfect solution to the challenges of teaching while wearing a mask, but it seems to offer quite a bit of volume and clarity. I also think it will reduce the fatigue of trying to project your voice through a mask all day, perhaps making this tricky back-to-school a tiny bit easier.


​There are a number of these devices available online, and the one I have is not a particularly sophisticated piece of equipment. I was excited, however, to see how well it worked while wearing a mask. Here are a few tips:
  • When the microphone gets near the speaker, you will get screeching feedback, similar to when you use a handheld microphone near a full-sized amplifier. I've found it works best to attach the speaker to your waist and put on the headphones before turning the volume up.
  • The microphone rests on your right ear, so it competes with your mask, as you will see in the video.
  • The device I have charges with a USB connected to my computer. I have never used it for a full day, but I have used it for many hours at a time and I have never had to recharge it. Amazon says that it stays charged for 8 hours and requires 3-5 hours to charge fully.
  • Here is the device on Amazon. (This is not an affiliate link.) It runs around $60.
  • Anything that bumps the cord will be amped. When I first experimented with it my earings were bumping the wire.
  • If you choose to put the microphone inside your mask, please consult with someone to make sure you aren't creating gaps in your facial coverage.
6 Comments

Breathing Lessons: The First Routine You Should Teach Your Students This Fall

7/21/2020

4 Comments

 
Picture
EveWhen I am stressed (angry, afraid, nervous, etc.), I inadvertently hold my breath. In those moments, my husband will sometimes notice and ask, "Are you breathing, Babe?" At that point, I exhale with a rush of air and pay attention to what I am doing (and not doing) with my lungs! I am always struck by my unconscious response of holding my breath. Realizing that I often don't breathe when I most need to has led me to actually practice breathing.

Perhaps this sounds silly. Breathing is automatic, right? Well, sort of. While we have natural rhythms to our breath, intentionally filling and emptying our lungs completely requires focus and practice.

One of my favorite times to intentionally practice breathing is anytime I am waiting. Because I use technology to teach, I am regularly asking whole groups of adults to wait. To wait for a hiccup in the wifi. To wait for a video to load. To wait for a website to respond. In these moments I often teach breathing lessons. I just engage us all in taking several slow deep breaths. I am always startled by how satisfying such technology glitches can be, when a whole room full of teachers simultaneously tune into their breath. Everyone seems to realize just how much stress we carry with us, and we're to find an antidote that was literally under our noses.

You too can use a technological pause as an opportunity to breathe deeply with your students. Inevitable tech hiccups can also offer spontaneous but regular practice of in-the-moment breathing routines in your classrooms. You can lay the groundwork for these incidental breathing lessons by launching the school year with a formal-ish breathing lesson.

​Conscious breathing is an antidote to worry, at a time when we can all find much to worry about. Even if it is a bit complicated by wearing masks, it is worth the effort. Here are a few books you might use to anchor your breathing lessons: 
Picture

​​The Breathing Book by Christopher Willard and Olive Weisser, includes a series of exercises to help students become aware of their breath. It is so beautifully practical, and even includes a breathing practice where you sit and hold a book. 

Picture

​Breathe with Me: Using Breath to Feel Calm, Strong, and Happy by Miriam Gates refers to breathing as a "superpower." This book is so relatable for young children and includes specific breathing strategies to try in different situations.

Picture

I Am Peace: A Book of Mindfulness by Susan Verde and illustrated by Peter H. Reynolds, speaks to the relief that taking a breath offers in a moment of worry. It is a lovely text for introducing the idea that we can learn to manage our minds.


​I invite you to use one of these books to introduce children to the idea that they can intentionally use their breath to serve them in moments of worry. This year promises some stress and some technology hiccups--opportunities to practicing breathing. When there is so much that we can't control for our students, especially this year, teaching them a breathing routine offers them the seed of a habit that can serve them for their entire lives. 

And if you feel like you need to take a deep breath yourself, you might consider this book to help you get started. 

You can start now. Just breathe.

4 Comments

A-syn-chron-ous: Morphemes worth teaching

7/20/2020

1 Comment

 
Picture
ThI recently saw a Twitter post that called for replacing asynchronous with "anytime" and synchronous with "real time." Certainly these words are a mouthful! Children are likely to love learning them, however, even young children. 

Since learning to read words depends on hearing words and building our phonological lexicons (the brain's collection of every word we have ever heard), I really love the idea of children hearing the words synchronous and asynchronous and thinking about what they mean. 

Furthermore, synchronous and asynchronous are really juicy words when it comes to learning morphemes-- the smallest units of meaning in a language. Consider the morphemes in synchronous.

          syn = with, together
          chron = time
          ous = full of

So synchronous literally means "full of time together." And then, adding a- to the beginning of synchronous illustrates that this prefix negates the term, as in "not full of time together."

How fun is that?! And what a missed opportunity if we choose to replace them with "real time" and "anytime" instead!

But wait, there's more.

The most powerful benefit of children learning these two words and the morphemes that compose them is that these morphemes can help children later figure out other words built with the same parts. Such as,

                    photosynthesis
                    synchronize
                    synergistic
                    chronological
                    synthesizer
                    synonym
                    synopsis
                    anachronistic
                    chronograph
                    chronic
                    delicious
                    adventurous
                    conscious

The idea that learning a few morphemes and then repurposing them to build new words--kind of like the way my sons use Legos--is vocabulary learning magic. To teach children how to figure out words by using known parts is to truly empower them to do the work (and it is fun!). 

So, please, don't think of synchronous and asynchronous as terrible words that are too hard for children to learn. Think of them as invitations. Think of them as the powerful intersection between print and meaning, where reading process comes together.

​You don't have to water down the words you use with children, hampering the growth of their phonological lexicons. In fact, if we combine knowledge of morphemes with agentive vocabulary exploration during independent reading, the effects on vocabulary growth can be synergistic!

1 Comment

Virtually Face-to-Face (It’s all distance learning.)

7/18/2020

7 Comments

 
Picture

As educators all over the United States grapple with the back-to-school models that inevitably include simultaneous preparation for “face-to-face” learning and distance learning, there is an understandable sense of overwhelm. Teachers are faced with preparing for two different (or hybrid) and complicated learning environments. Not knowing which model will finally play out adds a distressing element of uncertainty.

Perhaps, however, shifting our mental model can help. We can reframe the two options --”face-to-face” vs. remote learning-- as variations of distance learning, rather than as two completely different models. Then, we can find commonalities between them and start our planning there. Rather than thinking of back-to-school as either face-to-face or at-a-distance, in actuality, everything is going to be distance learning, even when students are in classrooms and “face-to-face.” 

As I’ve been thinking through what fall instruction can look like, it has been helpful to stop thinking of it as two different options, and to frame both options as variations of the same theme. Both are distance learning, with one six feet apart and the other miles apart. So I can plan for instruction that helps me with both at once. Here are some examples:

  • Read Aloud:  If you are reading aloud to students, because they will be so spread out rather than on a carpet crowded together right in front of you, you will probably need to project the book. Whether you hold the illustrations under a document camera or read aloud in front of a webcam, even in the classroom, the six-feet-apartness of this fall’s face-to-face requires digital tools that bridge the space.
 
  • Phonics Instruction:  If you are teaching children to pronounce and blend phonemes (sounds), they will need to see your face and mouth, and hear you clearly. Masks, quite obviously, obstruct sight and sound as you try to teach this critical understanding. To compensate, you could pre-record some sound and blending lessons and activities. Use your webcam to really get up close on your face and over articulate as you pronounce the sounds. Whether you are distance teaching at six-feet-apart or from your home, the video will support you in teaching children how speech sounds are made.

  • Reading Assessments:  At the beginning of the year, you want to find out about children’s reading processes by listening to them read individually. How will you do this six-feet-apart, or even miles apart? You may need to set up a computer station where children can read aloud to you in a Zoom session from the other side of the room. You may need students reading into an ipad in a chat with you from six feet away. If students can use the same platforms they use when learning from home, then all of the procedures and routines you teach in the classroom will simultaneously prepare them should all learning become at-home learning once again.

  • Classroom Libraries:  As for the physical classroom library, it seems that children may be able to shop for books if there are few children in the library, they wear masks, and they wash their hands well before and after shopping (Check district guidelines on this!). Of course, this probably means book shopping less frequently, so you will want to put some time and energy into setting up a virtual classroom library. Whether you are in the school building with students or supporting distance learning in their homes, a virtual library will support independent reading. Make teaching children how to navigate this library one of your key routines as you launch the school year. Clare Landrigan has done a beautiful job helping teachers organize and curate virtual libraries. 

There aren’t easy answers to the complexities of back-to-school 2020, and the overwhelm we are all feeling is warranted. For me, however, as I think about how to support the teachers with whom I work, things became a bit unstuck when I stopped thinking about the home learning and school learning options as separate. It is all distance learning, friends, so perhaps we can begin planning accordingly.

​
7 Comments

Race. Retail. Therapy.

7/14/2020

7 Comments

 

I used to carry a very large, leather purse. It was actually a glorified computer bag. I loved it because, when I traveled, I could just slip my computer into it and go. With my relatively slight frame, I looked like a child playing dress-up. It made my gate uneven as I leaned to the right with the weight of it. If I wasn’t careful, I could just walk in circles.

Once, while waiting for my husband to run some errands downtown, I carried that giant purse into a local store to pass the time. I held some earrings up to my ears, caressed a camisole, and sniffed a candle, all before I realized that I was being followed. 

The sales clerk was not subtle or clever about the way she trailed behind me, pretending to straighten this or that. Once I realized that she assumed I was a shoplifter because of my big bag, I had to resist the urge to pitch a fit. To call her out in the store. To ask to speak to the manager. I didn’t do any of those things, but I have never been in that store since, and I don’t hesitate to tell the story to friends (chock full of can-you-believe-it-ness) whenever someone mentions that store.

That was probably not the first sales clerk who looked suspiciously at my bag, which was more carry-on luggage than purse. Other clerks were probably just more discreet, or maybe I was just more clueless.

I retired that purse. Now I carry something small--the opposite extreme, even. Something with room for a tissue and a throat lozenge. No one wants to be treated like a thief. But I keep thinking of that “incident,” and how offended I was to be considered a likely candidate for cramming a floral print dress into my bag.

My husband, who is Black, has dealt with similar experiences his whole life (although he has never carried a big purse.)




​As many of us have, I have been thinking about social injustice and recent atrocities. It is easy to feel useless or clueless in all this. As a White person, or really just as a person, I don’t want to say or do the “wrong” thing. I know I’m not alone in this hesitancy.

I recently saw a tweet where someone Black coached well-intentioned White people to take a list of other actions before asking a Black person to give them advice on how to be White right now. Our Black friends, who know how to talk us through all this stuff without us freaking out, can grow weary of us. 

So, as I’ve been measuring my words, hemming and hawing, trying to figure out what to do next because I want to do "something,” I didn’t immediately call on the educator friends of color that I usually turn to for advice. 

But eventually I broke down. I called a dear friend. I asked him how he was. He sighed heavily. He is on the frontline of educator conversations about race, and I could certainly imagine what was making him sigh at this point in history. But I was wrong.

What is actually most frustrating for him at the moment is trying to help one well-intentioned White person after another sort through their feelings and their responsibilities. It’s giving them the tough or kind love they need to muster the courage to step out. And even though he is counselor to children, parents, and teachers as they work through the grief associated with murders, such as the killings of Rayshard Brooks, George Floyd, Ahmaud Arbery, and Breonna Taylor, he has done this grief work enough to know his way around it, as horrible as it is. 

But the needy White people, like me, are the thing that is exhausting for him right now. Lots of us have been spurred to action, but we just aren't sure what that action should be. And we want to take action the "right" way.

And there I was, a whiny White woman on the phone asking him to tell me how to do the right thing. A woman who wants to pitch a fit because she feels she has the right to carry a purse large enough to steal a winter coat in without anyone assuming the worst of her. Someone calling for a pep talk because she’s afraid that she might be perceived as insensitive or racist or insight some fury on a social media platform. Heaven forbid. And he was his usual, generous self, of course, coaching me past looking for a way to be supportive enough without having to really put something on the line.

​
7 Comments

Change Begins with ourselves

11/19/2019

3 Comments

 
In my consulting work, I have pulled up alongside far too many beginning readers who--having been taught to read in explicit phonics programs--have inadvertently learned to neglect the meaning of what they are reading. They tend to deliberate laboriously in decoding a word--yes, an important process for beginning readers--when the context and the syntax could have confirmed their efforts and taken them from their phonetic approximation to the actual word. This is what the balanced literacy folks (and I count myself among them), refer to as “word callers.” This pattern of inattention to meaning--which leads to opportunity costs in teaching children that reading is about constructing meaning--is a legitimate problem with explicit phonics instruction.

On the other hand, I have pulled up alongside far too many beginning readers who--having been taught to read in a balanced literacy framework--have inadvertently learned to over rely on context as they problem-solve words. They often scour the picture for clues to words they could easily decode relying almost exclusively on context and moving on without looking closely at the print. This is what the phonics folks (and I count myself among them), refer to as “guessing.” This pattern of inattention to the print--which leads to opportunity costs in learning orthography--is a legitimate problem with balanced literacy.

It often seems that, on either side of this debate, there is only noise and anger. There are, however, very reasonable and thoughtful folks exploring the nuances of each perspective and trying to actually listen closely to the voices of others. 

This can be difficult for many of us, however, myself included.

Usually, this difficulty arises from the stories we tell ourselves...stories that aren't completely true. Before we make sweeping generalizations about an entire group of people--people who represent a range of ideas within a larger, general perspective--perhaps we can interrogate our beliefs about these people. To support this effort, I share The Work from Byron Katie, which is a five-step process for considering the ways our thinking tends to be biased towards self-preservation and protection of our egos. 

Step 1: 
If something someone says or does causes you distress, identify the underlying story/belief you are telling yourself, such as

    Balanced literacy folks do not believe in teaching students explicit or systematic phonics.
    OR
    Science of reading folks do not care if children learn to comprehend.
    OR
    Balanced literacy folks believe that learning to read is as easy as learning to talk.
    OR
  Science of reading folks don’t care if children read from dreary books and learn to         hate reading.

Step 2: 
Ask yourself if this belief is actually true. 

Your ego may jump up here and try to assert how accurate these extreme, negative statements are. Don’t overlook the ego’s need to be right, even at the expense of ourselves, our children, our relationships, etc. Perhaps you immediately recognize that these statements aren’t absolutely true. If so, skip step three. If you are still convinced that the statements above are absolutely true, then you will want to check out step three.

Step 3: 
Go deeper. Ask yourself if the statement is absolutely true? Are there any exceptions? Could there be places where this belief doesn’t hold up? Do you know anyone who appreciates the contributions of the "science of reading" and also has demonstrated a clear commitment to student engagement and great texts? Do you know anyone who ascribes to "balanced literacy" who is intentional about phonics instruction?

Of course, if you are honest with yourself (and you must be), you will recognize that there are circumstances where these statements are not true.

Step 4:
Think about how the negative belief affects you. Who are you when you believe this? How do you act? What do you say? How do you feel?

Consider who you would be without this belief. Would you be more open to possibilities? Would you be better able to listen? Would you be able to focus on and expand what is working? Would you be better able to find opportunities for connection? Would you judge others less? Would you judge yourself less?  

Step 5: 
Flip the statements and see if you can persuade your ego that these new statements are at least somewhat true, if not absolutely true.

    Balanced literacy folks believe in teaching students explicit or systematic phonics.
    OR
    Science of reading folks care if children learn to comprehend.
    OR
    Balanced literacy folks don’t believe that learning to read is as easy as learning to talk.
    OR
    Science of reading folks care if children learn to hate reading.

Notice the shift in your breathing and in your body tension as you actually step into the truth of these flipped statements. If you can believe in at least the possibility of these statements, despite the fact that you may have encountered some folks who seem to embody the opposites, then you are on your way. 

And then, if you want to move to ninja-level honesty, you can flip the statements in another way and consider the truth in them. For example,
    
Science of reading folks do not believe in teaching students explicit or systematic phonics. 
(Children in classrooms with explicit phonics programs can learn the elements of the print system without learning how to apply them independently, in context. In fact, this problem is pretty widespread.) 

Balanced literacy folks do not care if children learn to comprehend.  
(Children in balanced literacy classrooms can also develop issues with comprehension. 
In fact, this problem is pretty widespread.)

What does this extreme switch do to your perspective? Can we make space for the nuances within the perspectives with which we align? These latter points are an extreme, but they illustrates the ways that we construct realities that support our belief systems.


Looking at the issues in the perspectives with which you align is important, honest work that is well within the scope of our individual power. You will accomplish more in addressing these issues than in engaging in angry debates where both sides are so triggered that no one can hear anyone else or look honestly at themselves.

Until we consider the truth of the first set of flipped statements (i.e.,
Balanced literacy folks believe in teaching students explicit or systematic phonics; Science of reading folks care if children learn to comprehend.) we will find it difficult to actually hear each other and work together on behalf of children.

    
The takeaways here are these:
  • Referring to entire groups of people in generalizations is called stereotyping, and it is not helpful.
  • Both groups in this “debate” care about both aspects of learning to read--mastering the code and reading for meaning.
  • Some members of both groups are listening for what is missing in the “other side” rather than seeing the places we can come together and start a conversation. Of course, we all find what we are looking for.
  • Our egos are driven by a subconscious preservation systems that makes it scary to consider being wrong (or someone else being right).
  • None of this is as black-and-white as we would like for it to be.
3 Comments

Do you have books they can actually read?

10/26/2019

3 Comments

 
Picture
I recently had lunch with my dear mentor and she told me a story about working in a classroom and sitting with a first grade student who was just beginning to read. She asked him to share his independent reading book with her only to discover that it was much too hard for him to read on his own. They went together to the classroom library, which was beautifully organized by topic and areas of interest to the students. As it turned out, however, there was literally nothing in the classroom library that the reader could actually decode independently.

As you are assembling and organizing your classroom library consider the quality, the accessibility, and reading level of what is available to students. As Kim Yaris and I describe in Reading Wellness, at any given time students will be reading more than one text. For beginning readers, that should include variety in terms of difficulty. A single reader may have one or more picture books, which he or she may read by looking at the pictures and telling the story. Hopefully, he or she will also have some high-quality, controlled-vocabulary texts--decodable and/or patterned--to engage in the practice of decoding and constructing meaning.
3 Comments
<<Previous
Forward>>

      Follow This Blog . . .

    Submit
    FREE BOOKS

    Author

    Dr. Jan Burkins is a full-time writer, consultant, and professional development provider. 

    Categories

    All
    Assessment
    Asynchronous
    Back To School
    Back-to-school
    Balance
    Balanced Literacy
    Beginning Reading
    Books
    Breathing
    Classroom Library
    Comprehension
    Cue
    Decoding
    Distance Learning
    Educational Technology
    Fluency
    Free Books
    Guided Reading
    Hybrid Models
    Independent Reading
    Mask
    Masks
    Meaning
    Mental Models
    Mindfulness
    Morphemes
    New Year
    Personal Growth
    Phonemic Awareness
    Phonological Awareness
    Planning
    Preventing Misguided Reading
    Print
    Prompt
    Prompting
    Prompting Funnel
    Questioning
    Racism
    Read Aloud
    Reading Wars
    Reflection
    Research
    Routines
    Schedule
    Science Of Reading
    Shared Reading
    Social Justice
    SoR
    Sources Of Information
    Stories
    Synchronous
    Technology
    Text Selection
    The Great Debate
    Unit
    Virtual
    Virtual Guided Reading
    Vocabulary Instruction
    Wait Time
    Whiteness
    Who's Doing The Work?

    RSS Feed

Jan Miller Burkins Consulting, LLC
1720 Epps Bridge Parkway , Suite 108, #419, Athens, GA 30606

    Follow this blog/newsletter.

Submit

Contact Jan

  • Home
  • The Six Shifts
  • Online Classes
  • Consulting
  • Reading Art
  • About
  • Jan's Books
  • Contact
  • WDTW 3-5 Lesson Set Kits